It gets so much crazier
That motley drama — oh, be sure
It shall not be forgot!
With its Phantom chased forevermore,
By a crowd that seize it not
Through a circle that ever returneth in
To the self-same spot,
And much of Madness and more of Sin,
And Horror the soul of the plot.
A lot happening here. The motley drama? Must be all the commotion from the second stanza, right? The invisible wo!
I had this thought later too, what makes wo invisible? Isn't it always invisible? I guess you could see it in someone's expression. I don't know. Also very eldritch. Like you're just afflicted by pure maddening horror or something.
Anyway, I love how Poe gets really dramatic in these first two lines. He goes into this aside to the reader/audience, "oh, be sure!" And then I italicize all these lines but in the text only the word shall is italicized. So he's really selling it. I'll be honest though I don't really know what he's talking about. What was I going to forget again? The wo? It seems like an inside joke that I don't get.
And then he gets real abstract
With its Phantom chased forevermore,
by a crowd that seize it not
So like, the crowd is chasing the Phantom of this motley drama/wo? I think what he's saying is that mankind is stuck in this loop of like agitation and misery and it's almost like this trauma cycle that keeps repeating but no one really understands what's happening (?) That's how I interpret chasing the Phantom but not seizing it. This unending cycle of conflict and drama that doesn't resolve to anything. It just goes around and around. Which is reflected in the next lines
Through a circle that ever returneth in
To the self-same spot,
It's rotten to the core, essentially. This cycle doesn't go anywhere or lead to anything but back to itself.
And much of Madness and more of Sin,
and Horror the soul of the plot.
Again, like before, Poe can't stress enough how this stuff like madness and sin and horror are at the very basic level of existence. I love it. He's just doing so much. Did he really think this? The fun thing about Poe though is that he kind of makes it sexy. He's a showman about it.
Like he's not saying all this stuff in sort of a gritty realistic way that would actually make you reflect on the capacity for cruelty in the average human heart. Or how society makes us uncaring and blind to actual tragedy and horror. I think that kind of mundane horror and wretchedness underpins this poem but that's not what Poe is talking about here. He's talking about a kind of grand cosmic horror and misery and it's kind of like he's dishing gossip
--oh! be sure-- it SHALL not be forgot.
With the veils drowned in tears. And the bewings and the bedights. I mean tis an absolute gala night!
RIP Edgar Allan Poe. You would've loved My Chemical Romance.
But I really do think Poe is a compelling writer. He's got this haunting relentless energy that's undeniable and the man just knows how to turn a phrase.